Ram Gopal Verma Ka Department
Department by RGV |
The first word that comes out for
this film is “disappointment”. After watching Department, I seriously doubt whether he is the same director who
excelled with the underworld gangster movies like Shiva, Satya and Company.
RGV carved out a niche for himself, but lost his direction midway. After
producing and directing duds like Agyat,
James and the unbeatable Ram Gopal
Verma Ki Aag, we all expected he will say adieu to direction.
But here he makes a comeback.
This time armed with stars like Amitabh Bachchan and Sanjay Dutt. We expected
at least some substance here as RGV has given us the Sarkars with BigB. But nothing works out here in this failed
experiment. It is just another extension of his done-to-death gangster genre,
offering nothing new for the viewers.
Rana Dagubatti and Amitabh Bachchan in Department |
It’s a ‘good cop-bad cop’ story
depicting the same old mafia-police nexus in Mumbai underworld. The storyline
remains pretty predictable and boring most of the time. BigB plays
gangster-turned-politician who tries to influence the good cop (Rana Dagubatti)
by offering him a gift. Sanjay Dutt plays the bad cop who works for another
mafia don, and tries to include the good cop in his corrupt world. The good cop
refuses but declares a peaceful co-existence. How the story moves ahead with
all the politics and gang wars, is largely foreseeable for an RGV flick.
Rana Dagubatti and Sanjay Dutt |
The gory images, the mindless
gun-battle sequences add nothing extra to the numb narrative. The
cinematography, which RGV claims to be a novel style, is nothing more than a
torture for your eyes. It should not be taken for granted or abused just because
the technology allows you to do so. Weird angles, unnecessary track-shots, ugly
extreme close-ups with a fish eye lens, create nausea and induce migraine. It has been shot without a DoP and RGV started this trend with his movie Not a Love Story. The Director now is totally obsessed with this style of filming with different varieties of digital cameras with different formats. We have
seen RGV’s unusual camera angles in his previous films as well, but most of
them were creatively and aesthetically done, e.g. Company (Cinematography by
Hemant Chaturvedi) and Sarkar (Cinematography by Amit Roy). This is the reason
why a film largely depends on the DoP.
Amitabh Bachchan in Department |
Overall, it is a failed pointless
experiment by RGV, looks as if he does not care about the box-office
collections and makes the movies he wants to make. But that does not provide
him with a “License to kill” the mood of the viewers, and this is a heinous
crime. A bunch of filthy blood-splattering gun-battle sequences put together does not make a
film. On the top of that the nauseous Camera movements and angles add to the
agony. We request RGV to have mercy on the movie-goers and spare us from his
disasters.
another disaster from RGV..a well written review!
ReplyDeleteThanks Pankaj !!
DeleteThanks for the review
ReplyDeleteRothin Goswami
Thanks Rathin Da !!
DeleteWat a terrific review Pranjal! It has all the humour and wit which RGV's recent films lack :-). Department of course has to be avoided at any cost. RGV is behaving like a excited who gets a new toy (in this case digicams). What we get is a headache. Time to retire RGV?
ReplyDeleteAniruddha,
DeleteVery true..!! RGV is obsessed with his new toy (Digital Cameras) and giving us nausea. He should either retire or go to Bahamas for a vacation. ( May be after the collections of Department, his Finance Department won't allow him for an expensive n-th honeymoon, but still he can settle down for an affordable Bangkok-Pataya one.) Wot say u !! ?
And thanks for the kind words..!! Cheers !
Very nice. Would love to read more from you.
ReplyDeleteThanks Jutismita for the comment.
Deletevery well written indeed. the knowledge and the flow is awesome. but RGV is a lost case. RGV is a mad cow still chewing its cud from last century.
ReplyDeleteThanks so much for the comment. May I know your name..as it is shown here as Unknown.
DeleteThanks
very well written review, keep it up !
ReplyDeleteThanks Pervez
DeleteHey, thanks for the review Pranjal... Well commented, can visualise the pointless experiment by RgVee through your writing. You are a saver! You've saved my time a great deal... :D
ReplyDeleteThanks Das.
ReplyDeleteRGV ... trying to follow the footsteps of Devanand .... the film maker.... hw is virtually trying to personally feel what it is to fail like Devanand after such a Great Success history....
ReplyDeleteAll the best RGV and to Pranjal - the writer....
Actually watching "Department" was a pathetic pain in A**.. I was a fan of RGV for his experimental story telling and cinematography. Though the story was ok ok type, at the same time cinematography went nowhere.. I was wired and distracted experience.
ReplyDelete